History Podcasts

What is the story behind the tall Northern offshoot on the West Virginia map?

What is the story behind the tall Northern offshoot on the West Virginia map?

It seems like such a tall thin slice should have a story.


Some colonies, including Virginia, claimed all land to their west. Other states, including Pennsylvania, had defined western boundaries:

Ever since the proprietary grant to William Penn in 1681, the border between Virginia and Pennsylvania had depended upon defining the eastern edge of Pennsylvania. Once that eastern edge of Pennsylvania was resolved, surveyors could locate a north-south line "five degrees in longitude, to bee computed from the said Easterne Bounds… " to mark the western edge of Pennslvania. Until then, land speculators in Pennsylvania chartered the Indiana Company, while Maryland speculators formed the Illinois and Wabash companies, and sought rights to the same lands being claimed by the Virginia-based Ohio Company. (source)

Here's a map showing the state of claims in 1755, with VA in brown and PA in yellow:

You'll note that the map isn't great. (Look how squat western PA is, because Lake Erie looks too far to the south.) Poor mapping gave states with unlimited western territories room to maneuver in making claims on western territory. Land to the west of PA's western border thus had the potential to be claimed by Virginia. Indian fighting and the Revolutionary War prevented the settling of the boundary dispute. All of this geographical ambiguity meant that settlers in this disputed area were confronted with dual local governments, one loyal to Pennsylvania and the other to Virginia:

… there were, west of the Alleghanies, not only two different sets of magistrates, with their subordinate officers, constables, assessors, and organized companies of militia, over the same people in the Monongahela valley, but within a few miles of each other had been established two different courts regularly (or irregularly) administering justice under the laws of two different governments. These conditions, with these Virginia Courts exercising judicial powers in the same territory with the courts of Pennsylvania, continued until August 2S, 1780. (source)

Upon peace with Britain, a final surveying trip was completed during 1784-1786. Having definitively set the southeastern corner of PA, the surveyors could then definitively set the western border of PA. But by then, the Land Ordinance of 1785 gave all territory north of the Ohio River to the federal government, which would sell the land in order to raise revenue and (eventually) form new states. So Virginia was left with the tiny sliver of land west of Pennsylvania and south of the Ohio River. And of course, West Virginia took control of the panhandle after the Wheeling Convention of 1861.


The two key states in this drama were Virginia and Pennsylvania. The former, Virginia, initially claimed all of the land west of it all the way to the Mississippi River, with the Ohio River as its northern border. On the other hand, Pennsylvania, founded by the orderly and pacifist William Penn, defined itself as a rectangle (except where geographical features like the Delaware River in the east, and Lake Erie in the northwest prevailed), with the boundaries of 42 degrees to the north, 80 degrees 31 minutes to the west, and the Mason-Dixon line to the south.

After the founding of the United States, the 13 colonies were asked to limit their western claims to roughly the line of the Alleghany and Cumberland mountains to allow for the creation of new states to the west. This led to a partial "rollback" of Virginia's claims out of modern Kentucky, paving the way for the 15th state. When Ohio became the 17th state, it adopted the Pennsylvania border as its eastern boundary only as far south as the Ohio River, and the Ohio River itself as a "southern" boundary. This created the sliver of land between Pennsylvania's western boundary and the Ohio River (which veered to the southwest instead of due west) that was left in the hands of Virginia. Ohio may have done this in order to have a defensible border and avoid the fights the preceded the establishment of the Mason-Dixon line.

This realignment also began a debate as to whether Virginia should pull back further to (roughly) its current western borders, leaving room for the modern state of West Virginia. That debate was settled in June, 1861 at the Wheeling Convention, as "West Virginia's" response to the start of the Civil War, and Virginia's secession from the Union.


Books Read in 2020

Patterson, James: The Last Days of John Lennon
This book was not what the title led me to expect. The author spends more time on telling the history of the Beatles than on dealing with the last days of Lennon and his murder. Still, pretty good book, especially for Beatles and/or Lennon fans. (***)

Brooks-Dalton, Lily: Good Morning, Midnight: A Novel
Something catastrophic has happened on earth, leaving one scientist and a mysterious little girl stranded in the Arctic and five astronauts in space on their flight home from Jupiter. One of the best books I've read in a while. Inspiration for Netflix's film "Midnight Sky." (****)

Hendrix, Grady: The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
I'm not a fan of vampire books. In fact, the only ones that have ever earned good reviews from me are DRACULA and INTERVIEW WITH A VAMPIRE. I can now add a third. I found the beginning of this book to be humorous. I could readily relate to this group of ladies who think of themselves as "just housewives." Later on, when they put on their badass panties (and the author pretty much dropped the humor) and fight against evil for their families and neighbors, I could relate to that too--although I can't say I've ever fought anything as gross and evil as James Harris. (****)

Sager, Riley: Home Before Dark: A Novel
Is it a ghost story or a murder mystery? You'll have to read to the end to find out. When I began reading, I thought it was going to be an Amityville Horror knockoff, but I was wrong. Good read. Exciting page turner. Note: The title really doesn't fit. I don't know where that came from. I think I would have titled it The Ghosts of Baneberry Hall. The word "dark" seems to be a draw these days, in novels and in Netflix movies. (***)

Haig, Matt: The Midnight Library: A Novel
Matt Haig gives us truly imaginative plots and story lines. In this book, a young woman, Nora, can find no meaning nor purpose in her life and finally decides to end it. After taking the pills, she finds herself in what appears to be an endless library with her librarian, Miss Elm, who explains to Nora that each of the endless supply of books will take her to a life that she is living in a parallel universe. The purpose: to give Nora a reason for living and get rid of her many regrets. The book reminds me just a tiny bit of THE WIZARD OF OZ. (****)

Coben, Harlan: The Boy from the Woods
Thirty years ago, Wilde was found as a boy living feral in the woods, with no memory of his past. Now an adult, he still doesn't know where he comes from, and another child has gone missing. I was pretty dissatisfied with the ending. (***)

North, Alex: The Shadows: A Novel
25 years ago, a group of teenage boys participated in a ritualistic murder. One murderer was apprehended, the other, Charlie Crabtree, disappeared without a trace. Linked to the crime, Paul Adams left his hometown without looking back. Forced to return home to visit his dying mother, it appears a copycat is on the loose. Part horror novel, part detective story, part mystery. At times I enjoyed the story, but at times, it seemed to bog down. (***)

Little, Bentley: The Haunted
A very scary haunted house book--but the sex and violence, in my opinion, crept over into the gratuitous category. I'm no prude. I like scary books with lots of danger, and I don't mind a little sex. This one jsut went a little too far for me. But plenty scary. (***)

Follett, Ken: Third Twin: A Novel of Suspense
Scientist Jeannie Ferrami stumbles across a baffling mystery: Steve and Dan appear to be identical twins, but were born on different days, to different mothers. A law student and a convicted murderer, they seem a world apart, but as Jeannie begins to fall in love with Steve, who is charged with a horrendous crime he swears he didn't commit, she finds her professional - and personal - future threatened. A true page turner. (****)

Jewell, Lisa: The Family Upstairs: A Novel
Twenty-five years ago, police were called to 16 Cheyne Walk with reports of a baby crying. When they arrived, they found a healthy ten-month-old happily cooing in her crib in the bedroom. Downstairs in the kitchen lay three dead bodies, all dressed in black, next to a hastily scrawled note. And the four other children reported to live at Cheyne Walk were gone. In this chilling novel, the author brings us the can’t-look-away story of three entangled families living in a house with the darkest of secrets. (****)

Napolitano, Ann: Dear Edward: A Novel
Best book I’ve read in months, maybe years. At 12 years of age, Eddie (Edward) Adler survives an airline crash in which 191 people die, everyone except him, including his mom, dad, and older brother. For the next six years, Edward struggles to find his place in a world without his family. I highly recommend this book. (*****)

Hudson, Suzanne: The Fall of the Nixon Administration
This is a silyl book. And if you were to remove all the profanity, obscenity, and pornography, you wouldn’t have three paragraphs left, nor a story (which you don’t have much of anyway). The only good thing about this book is the chickens. But it does have some funny dialogue. So I’ll give it three starts for that. (***)

Levy, Andrea: Small Island: A Novel
Hortense Joseph arrives in London from Jamaica in 1948 with her life in her suitcase, her heart broken, her resolve intact. Her husband, Gilbert Joseph, returns from the war expecting to be received as a hero, but finds his status as a black man in Britain to be second class. His white landlady, Queenie, raised as a farmer's daughter, befriends Gilbert, and later Hortense, with innocence and courage, until the unexpected arrival of her husband, Bernard, who returns from combat with issues of his own to resolve. (***)

Kehlmann, Daniel: You Should Have Left: A Novel
Super chilling story of a writer who can’t seem to write anything except notes to himself. He and his wife and 4-year-old daughter have retreated to a secluded house in the German mountains so that he can finish a screenplay. Things do not go well. (****)

Erdrich, Louise: The Last Report on the Miracles at Little No Horse: A Novel
This was our book club selection for August. I found it sort of cumbersome and confusing. There were far too many characters to keep track of, and many of the characters were more than one person. If you’re interested in the plot, click on the link and read about it on Amazon. I’m to tired of this book to go into detail. (**)

Morgenstern, Erin: The Starless Sea: A Novel
A mythical story about stories, is how one reviewer describes this book. Did I like it? I did at the beginning and for maybe halfway through. But so much description, repetition, and repetition of descriptions got on my last nerve, and I confess I didn’t quite finish the book. I just found that I didn’t care much how it ended, so I gave up. But the premise was a good one. (***)

Adams, Taylor: No Exit: A Novel
On her way to Utah to see her dying mother, college student Darby Thorne gets caught in a fierce blizzard in the mountains of Colorado. With the roads impassable, she’s forced to wait out the storm at a remote highway rest stop. Inside are some vending machines, a coffee maker, and four complete strangers. Desperate to find a signal to call home, Darby goes back out into the storm . . . and makes a horrifying discovery. In the back of the van parked next to her car, a little girl is locked in an animal crate. (***)

Wright, Kim: Last Ride to Graceland
Blues musician Cory Ainsworth is barely scraping by after her mother’s death when she discovers a priceless piece of rock ‘n’ roll memorabilia hidden away in a shed out back of the family’s coastal South Carolina home: Elvis Presley’s Stutz Blackhawk, its interior a time capsule of the singer’s last day on earth. (***)

Haines, Carolyn: The Book of Beloved (Pluto's Snitch 1)
As a young woman widowed by World War I, Raissa James is no stranger to ghosts. But when an invitation arrives from Caoin House, her uncle’s estate in Mobile, Alabama, she’s finally ready to cast off the shadows of her past. A spooky old house, a gaggle of ghosts, and murder combine for a chilling read. (****)

Haines, Carolyn: Them Bones: A Mystery from the Mississippi Delta (Sarah Booth Delaney Mystery Book 1)
First in the Sarah Booth Delaney mysteries. Sarah Booth is over 30, unmarried, alone and broke, and about to lose the family plantation. She has her own personal ghost, the nanny of her great great grandmother. When kidnapping her friend’s doggie Chablis with plans exchange her for ransom falls through, Chablis’s owner hired Sarah Booth to solve a murder. Thus begins this someone unlikely southern belle’s career as a sleuth. (***)

King, Stephen: If It Bleeds
I enjoyed the first three novellas in this collection. But the 4th one, the title story “If It Bleeds,” is a continuation of the Bill Hodges/Holly Gibney saga. I got tired of them halfway through the first book, I think. I didn’t finish this one.Four stars for first three stories, two stars for “If It Bleeds." (***)

King, Stephen: The Outsider: A Novel
An eleven-year-old boy’s violated corpse is discovered in a town park. Eyewitnesses and fingerprints point unmistakably to one of Flint City’s most popular citizens—Terry Maitland, Little League coach, English teacher, husband, and father of two girls. Detective Ralph Anderson, whose son Maitland once coached, orders a quick and very public arrest. Maitland has an alibi, but Anderson and the district attorney soon have DNA evidence to go with the fingerprints and witnesses. (***)

McBride, James: The Good Lord Bird: A Novel
Henry Shackleford is a young slave living in the Kansas Territory in 1857, when the region is a battleground between anti- and pro-slavery forces. When John Brown, the legendary abolitionist, arrives in the area, an argument between Brown and Henry’s master quickly turns violent. Henry is forced to leave town—with Brown, who believes he’s a girl. (***)

Ng, Celeste: Little Fires Everywhere: A Novel
I had some trouble getting into this book. But about halfway through, I was hooked. Most of the main characters are teenagers. And most of the grownup characters aren't very well fleshed out, with maybe the exception of Mia. Sort of like Charlie Brown grownups. I was a little disappointed with the book as a whole. (***)

Coben, Harlan: Gone for Good: A Novel
Will Klein’s older brother Ken was his hero. Then, on a warm suburban night in the Kleins’ affluent New Jersey neighborhood, a young woman is found murdered. The prime suspect: Ken Klein. Ken vanishes, and for ten years, his family has no word from him. They are sure he is gone for good--until a decade later, on her death bed, Will’s mother gives Will reason to think otherwise. (***)

Karen Thompson Walker: The Dreamers: A Novel
A plague has hit this small college town. People are falling asleep and not waking up. But that’s only the beginning. What happens to them in their dreams is the real story. I loved this book. It reminded me a bit of SLEEPING BEAUTIES by Stephen and Owen King. (****)

Harlan Coben: The Stranger
The stranger digs around in people’s private lives to learn secrets they’d like to keep secret, then blackmails them (or sometimes he just tells them to ruin lives) to keep their secrets. A page turner for me. (***)

Kristin Hannah: Firefly Lane
I rarely give up on a book once I start reading it. But this is the second book I failed to finish this year. It reads like a book for young girls. Not this author’s best effort. I can’t believe the same woman who wrote THE NIGHTINGALE wrong this. (**)

Sarah M. Broom: The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)
This was my book club’s February selection. I know it won awards. I know it gets glowing reviews. I admit the writer has a way with words. But I found this book tedious and slow going. I couldn’t keep the characters straight, so I finally gave up trying to remember who was who. Eventually, I gave up on the whole book. Didn’t finish it. (**)

Taylor Adams: No Exit: A Novel
A kidnapped little girl, two psychopathic killers, and a blizzard combine to make a rip-roaring thriller. I really enjoyed this one. (****)

Michael Crummey: The Innocents: A Novel
A brother and sister are orphaned in an isolated cove on Newfoundland's northern rocky, wild coastline. Still children with only the barest notion of the outside world, they have nothing but the family's boat and the little knowledge passed on haphazardly by their mother and father to keep them. (****)

Susan May: Best Seller
A young female writer is mentored by an experienced award-winning male author. Female writer’s career takes off, while male author’s hits the skids. Then all hell breaks loose. This is one of the best thrillers, and most original plots, I’ve ever read. I can recommend it gladly to all thriller lovers. (****)

List of site sources >>>


Watch the video: Ντοκιμαντέρ για την επέτειο της 28ης Οκτώβρη (January 2022).